Captain American't: Can Steve Rogers defeat the Red Skull and make it to the performance of his 2:30 show? We'd say he Captain American't!
My Supernatural Sweet 16: The Winchester Brothers from Supernatural face the scariest monster yet: a teenage girl named Ashlyn. Unfortunately they realized they have wrong address, they supposed to took 666 but instead took 664
- MAD News - The MAD News anchor announces that Mila Kunis escorts a lucky officer to a Military Ball.
- Opening Scene
- Captain American't (Movie Parody of Captain America: the First Avenger)
- Animated Marginals segment
- Stork has napkins that aren't wrinkled (Animated by Mike Wartella)
- Ghost Rider's Training Wheels (Spoof on Ghost Rider) (Ad Parodies segment) (Animation by Mark Marek)
- Tomato, Tomahto (Cartoon)
- How I Left Your Brother (at a Highway Rest Stop) (TV Parody of How I Met Your Mother) (Cartoon)
- Mouse doesn't want cheese at the end of Applebee's Maze (Restaurant Parody of Applebee's) (Stop-motion Cartoon segment)
- Spy vs. Spy - Bomb Surfboard (Spy vs. Spy segment)
- Celebrity Superpowers (Celebrity Superpowers segment)
- Animated Marginals segment
- Clifford's Notes (TV/Book Parody of Clifford the Big Red Dog / Spoof on CliffsNotes) (Ad Parodies segment)
- The Tin Man steals the heart (Spoof on the Tin Man from MGM's the Wizard of Oz) (Animated by Mike Wartella)
- My Supernatural Sweet 16 (TV Parody of My Super Sweet 16 and Supernatural)
- 5-second Cartoon - (from My Supernatural Sweet 16) Sam says, "I can't believe I got a skull as a party favor!" and Dean says, "I can't believe that I found shoes for the dress!" (5-second Cartoon segment)
- Main article: Captain American't / My Supernatural Sweet 16/Gallery
- This is the very first time Ghost Rider appeared, and the only time My Super Sweet 16 gets parodied.
- This is the second time Clifford the Big Red Dog appeared.
- This is the third time Supernatural and How I Met Your Mother appeared.
- In the "Stork has napkins that aren't wrinkled" cartoon, the half of the music is from Pinocchio 2: Boy, Oh Boy, Real Life is Hard from Episode 28.
- Fred Tatasciore and Tara Strong do the voices of Rick and Mouse, just like Storybook Weaver and Storybook Weaver DeLuxe.
- Hugh Davidson - Bucky, Big Kid, Dad, Stork, and Possessed Girl's Dad
- Brian T. Delaney - Jack Black, Kid, and Sam Winchester
- Will Friedle - Captain America and DJ
- Jim Meskimen - Chester Phillips, Teacher, Doctor, and Ashlyn's Dad
- Rachel Ramras - Lady Gaga, Girl, and Tomato
- Kevin Shinick - Abraham Erskine, Red Skull, Dean Winchester, Gollum, Tin Man, Johnny Blaze, Devil's Dad, How I Left Your Brother (at a Highway Rest Stop) Announcer, and the MAD News Anchor
- Tara Strong - Margaret Carter, Ashlyn, Kid's Mom, and Mouse
- Fred Tatasciore - Nick Fury, Devil, Rick, Clifford's Notes Announcer and Celebrity Superpowers Announcer